My wife and I agree we both came to the same conclusion.
I think sometimes wine critics are on crack. They completely miss ratted this wine. It should have been 100+ is was such a nice wine full bodied and full of flavor and aromas.

There was one glass left in the bottle. I thought I would just finish it off. So I poured myself a glass and as I did I could see the coloring was a Red with a nice purple. I could scents of Earth and minerals and Cassis. This wine was Fruity and full bodied.